New Year’s Resolutions vs. Reality: Avoiding the "January Spike" in Gym Injuries

Key Takeaways:
  • The "January Spike" in injuries often results from increasing workout intensity too quickly.
  • Shin splints and rotator cuff tendonitis are common signs of overuse.
  • Ignoring early pain signals can turn a minor setback into a surgical issue.
  • MidAmerica’s Sports Medicine team helps you modify activity to heal while staying active.

January is a month of ambition. Gyms across the Chicago suburbs are packed with motivated individuals ready to transform their health. We see people running their first miles, lifting heavy weights, and joining high-intensity interval training classes.

We applaud this drive. Restoring quality of life is central to our mission. However, there is a predictable pattern we see every year around the third week of January. We call it the "Resolution Spike."

Enthusiasm often outpaces physical conditioning. When you increase the frequency or intensity of your workouts too abruptly, your body may struggle to adapt. If you are currently feeling a nagging pain in your shins, shoulders, or knees, you are not alone. More importantly, you need the right support to ensure this setback doesn’t end your fitness journey for the year.

The Science of "Too Much, Too Soon"

Your body is incredibly adaptive, but it requires time to strengthen tendons and ligaments. Muscles grow stronger relatively quickly, but the connective tissues that support them have a slower metabolic rate.

When you jump from a sedentary autumn into a high-intensity January, you create a gap between what your muscles can do and what your joints can handle. This creates inflammation.

Consider the "Weekend Warrior" or the returning athlete. You might feel great during the workout due to adrenaline. The next morning, however, you wake up with stiffness that doesn't go away after a warm shower. This is your body signaling that you have exceeded its current load capacity.

Common Resolution Injuries

At our Sports Medicine Clinic, we treat a specific set of injuries that arise during this season. Recognizing them early is the key to a fast recovery.

Shin Splints (Medial Tibial Stress Syndrome)

This is common among new runners or those returning to the treadmill. It manifests as a sharp or throbbing pain along the inner edge of the shin bone. It is caused by repetitive stress on the shinbone and the connective tissues that attach your muscles to the bone. Ignoring this can lead to stress fractures.

Rotator Cuff Tendonitis

If your resolution involves overhead lifting, swimming, or CrossFit, your shoulders are at risk. The rotator cuff is a group of small muscles that stabilize the shoulder. Sudden increases in overhead volume can irritate these tendons. Pain usually strikes at night or when reaching behind your back.

Patellar Tendonitis (Jumper's Knee)

This affects the tendon connecting your kneecap to your shinbone. It is frequent in activities involving jumping or heavy squatting. The pain is usually localized right below the kneecap and worsens with activity.

Don't Quit. Modify.

The biggest mistake patients make is an "all or nothing" approach. When pain strikes, they stop working out entirely. This can be discouraging and lead to abandoning your health goals.

The better approach is to consult a specialist who understands the athlete's mindset. At MidAmerica Orthopaedics, our goal isn't to bench you. It is to modify your training so you can heal while maintaining fitness.

We might recommend swapping the treadmill for a stationary bike to reduce impact while your shins heal. We might prescribe Physical Therapy to strengthen the stabilizer muscles around your shoulder. We act as your partners in this journey.

When to See a Specialist

How do you know if you can push through or if you need a doctor? We recommend the "Rule of Three."

  1. Pain Scale: If the pain is sharp (not just sore) and exceeds a 3 out of 10.
  2. Duration: If the pain lasts more than 3 days without improvement.
  3. Function: If the pain alters how you walk, lift, or move.

If you meet these criteria, self-medicating with ibuprofen is not the solution. You need a diagnosis.

Your Comeback Starts Here

A gym injury is a hurdle, not a stop sign. Our team at MidAmerica Orthopaedics is committed to restoring your quality of life. We offer a compassionate team-delivery approach that brings together physicians and physical therapists to build a recovery plan tailored to your specific goals.

Call to Action: Keep your resolutions alive by training smart. If you are experiencing pain from a new workout routine, schedule an evaluation with our Sports Medicine Clinic. Call (708) 237-7200 to book an appointment in Palos Hills or Mokena.

When an Injury Occurs

Direct To Specialist The First Time

Our Mission is to foster hope, healing, and well-being through our compassionate team-delivery approach by trusted experts who are committed to restoring the quality of life to individuals of all ages.
Copyright © 2026 MidAmerica Orthopaedics
Site Design by Swarm Interactive
MidAmerica Orthopaedics